The Betrayal

Natural Born Citizen - A Place to Ask Questions and Get the Right Answers Published

Saturday, January 21, 2012

The McClellan/Obama Citizenship Debate and the Natural Born Citizen Clause

The McClellan/Obama Citizenship Debate and the Natural Born Citizen Clause

By Mario Apuzzo, Esq.
January 21, 2012



George B. McClellan


Dr. Conspiracy likes to give the appearance of being an unbiased scholar in pursuit of the truth regarding whether putative President Barack Obama is a “natural born Citizen.” He has also created an internet persona of being a champion of civil rights. He has even gone as far as to take the unabashed position that most people who question Obama’s “natural born Citizen” status are racists. To date, he has made no apologies for his outlandish position.

At his blog, http://www.obamaconspiracy.org/2012/01/mcclellans-citizenship/ , Dr. Conspiracy has posted a story published in The Boston Globe on November 9, 1903, entitled “McClellan’s Citizenship. Question of Eligibility for Presidency.” The story can be read at http://www.obamaconspiracy.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/McClellan.pdf .  The story is about whether George B. McClellan, then newly-elected Mayor of New York City, but who was born in Europe to U.S. citizen parents (his father was Civil War General McClellan), was a “natural born Citizen” and therefore eligible to be President. By looking at his picture posted by Dr. Conspiracy, Colonel McClellan was surely white, but yet American citizens raised the question of whether he was a “natural born Citizen.” Note that Dr. Conspiracy does not tell us that even though McClellan was white (and so was John McCain and George Romney who were also challenged), he was challenged by presumably other whites on his eligibility to be President. So I guess that it is after all possible to challenge a political candidate on his eligibility for a particular office without being motivated by race.
[Read more →]

Tags: Mario Apuzzo, eligibility by David-Crockett
No Comments »

As reported here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here. Montana, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Arizona, Texas, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Indiana, Connecticut and Missouri are pursuing legislation that will require presidential and vice-presidential candidates prove their Constitutional Eligibility to be placed on the ballot. Now, Georgia joins that growing list with the backing of 94 Georgia Legislators. …It would be nice if these reporters would get their facts straight…

[Read more →]

Tags: Georgia, eligibility by David-Crockett
6 Comments »

Natural Born Citizen - A Place to Ask Questions and Get the Right Answers published

Ad - Obama Ineligible! 21 Feb 2011 issue Washington Times National Weekly edition - page 5.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/49213761/Obama-Ineligible-21-Feb-2011-Washington-Times-National-Weekly-edition-pg-5

Citizen maybe, but NOT a “natural born Citizen” of the United States.

Obama is not Article II constitutionally eligible to be the President and Commander of our military. Obama is NOT a “natural born Citizen” to constitutional standards. Obama’s father was NOT a U.S. Citizen. Obama’s father was not an immigrant to the United States. Obama’s father was a foreign national, a British Subject. Obama is the child of an alien father who was sojourning in the U.S. attending college. Obama was born a British Subject via his father and is still such to this day. Obama has never conclusively proved he was born in Hawaii. Obama’s paternal family in Kenya, Kenyan government officials, and newspapers in Kenya say he was born in Kenya. Obama’s maternal grandmother likely falsely and illegally registered him as born in Hawaii to get him, her new foreign-born grandson, U.S. Citizenship.
[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, Mario Apuzzo, eligibility by David-Crockett
7 Comments »

CONSTITUENT EDUCATES SENATOR ON THE MEANING OF “NATURAL BORN CITIZEN”

February 9, 2011

Senator Roy Blunt
Dirksen Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C.  20510

Dear Senator Blunt:

I am grateful for your reply to my letter of January 7 regarding eligibility requirements, but I am disappointed in your response for several reasons.

1.  You must be an honorable man, but you completely ignored the fact that at the time of his birth, Barack H. Obama II owed allegiance to Great Britain. That is not disputed, it is admitted by Obama himself.  Thus you failed to respond to the central point of my letter:  because Obama’s father was a foreigner, Obama II is not a “natural born Citizen” (nbC), regardless of where he was born, and is therefore ineligible for the presidency.  I pointed out that nbC is different from plain citizen, but you write as if the only question is whether Obama was born in Hawaii.  It is impossible for someone born with foreign allegiance to be nbC.

[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, eligibility by David-Crockett
3 Comments »

Video: Funny how it is no problem when a flaming Liberal can ask Robert Gibbs a “birther” question without being ridiculed for it. I guess when Sarah Palin’s name is involved then all is good. Just days ago WND’s White House correspondent was practically laughed out of the room when he asked a simple question regarding the 10+ states seeking proof of constitutional eligibility from presidential candidates. Have they no shame!? Video below transcript. Previous reports on Obama’s propagandist can be found here, here, here, here and here.
[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, eligibility by David-Crockett
No Comments »

Lawmaker files new bill to require presidential candidates be qualified
© 2011 WorldNetDaily

WASHINGTON – And then there were 11.

The push at the state level to ensure no future president enters office under the cloud of suspicion that he or she might not be constitutionally eligible is growing.

At the request of a local tea-party group, Tennessee state Sen. Mae Beavers has filed a bill that would require presidential candidates to show an original birth certificate establishing constitutional eligibility for the office before getting on the ballot beginning in 2012.

[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, eligibility by David-Crockett
2 Comments »

A New Interview with Former Senior Hawaii Election Official Tim Adams: Obama Birth Certificate Never Existed in Hawaii; Arrogant that Obama Doesn’t Have to Answer to the American People. Hat tip Protect Our Liberty.

Via First American; - Obama Birth Certificate – “Never Existed in Hawaii” - Taylor Hardy

Tim Adams agreed to a telephone interview and we spoke on February 3, 2011. Within the first couple of minutes of the interview I tossed my questions that I had formulated before speaking with him. Listen to your gut is sometimes hard advice to follow and this time I’m glad I listened to my instincts.

I think there was some apprehension as I spoke with Tim. The saying that first initial impressions count and they do –I think Tim is a standup guy and I felt he’s a man with honest intentions not out to hurt anyone or to push some political bent. Our phone interview lasted approximately 59 minutes followed up by email.

[Read more →]

Tags: Hawaii investigation, Obama records, Obama research, eligibility by David-Crockett
4 Comments »

The Right Side Of Life published

Blogger “Ulsterman” has posted another alleged communication from the same former White House insider, this time claiming to detail that conversations are going on related to the eligibility issue. In short, as one commenter — “MJ” — to the posting said, “Birthers [are] living rent free in Obama’s head:”

…Second focus was apparently “birther” related.  Jarrett expressed concern over possible newly passed eligibility requirements in states.  If only one or two states clarify eligibility in order to run for office, White House will simply use those states as examples of “anti-Obama racism”.  They would likely not win the electorals in those states regardless, but could use the scenario to gain sympathy and support over the challenge from other moderate states.  This is the tactic Jarrett and crew have prepared.  She is worried though that if more than one or two states challenge the president’s eligibility, the issue would turn against them.  Measures are being taken to make certain that does not happen.  What those measures are, I don’t know at this point.  Oh, and while discussion over eligibility was underway, Obama sat motionless.  He said nothing.  That strikes me as pretty damn odd don’t you think?  People are discussing whether or not you are actually eligible to run for re-election in 2012 and you don’t say a word on the subject?  “He just sat there with a weird little smile and didn’t say anything.”  Go ahead and print that quote word for word.  Others are now willing to let their observations be more known.  Concern for the country is now winning over concern for their own political interests.  Finally.

Commenter “Christina” helped Ms. Jarrett out a little bit by providing a current listing of States considering eligibility measures:

[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, eligibility by David-Crockett
1 Comment »

Hon. James David Manning, PhD interviews Dr. Jerome Corsi on Hawaii Governor Neil Abercrombie not finding Obama’s Birth Certificate. Recorded on 27 January 2011. Go to http://atlah.org and http://atlahmedianetwork.org for more information.

Tags: Dr. Chiyome Fukino, Hawaii investigation, Philip J. Berg, The Honorable James David Manning, eligibility by David-Crockett
No Comments »

Congress acted on misinformation and lies in 2008 2009, Obama eligibility, Congressmen better pay attention now

“Why has Obama, for over 2 years, employed numerous private and government attorneys to avoid presenting a legitimate birth certificate and college records?”…Citizen Wells and millions of concerned Americans

[Read more →]

Tags: eligibility by David-Crockett
47 Comments »

“WE NEED TO FOCUS LIKE A LASER ON THE ELIGIBILITY ISSUE”
by Sharon Rondeau

(Sept. 2, 2010) — Dr. Kate holds a Bachelor’s degree from Smith College in geology and a doctorate in hydrology from the University of Arizona.  She has worked in the field of Indian water rights for the last 30 years.   A professional resource manager with substantial legal training, Dr. Kate describes the laws governing Indian water rights as “very complex.”  Her role has been to find solutions to water resource problems for Native Americans.

When we asked her if she was an attorney, Dr. Kate told us, “It is just as much of a surprise to me that I could end up on this end and having people think that I’m a lawyer.  No, I’m not; I’m just extremely concerned about our country.  Fortunately, my training has required me to do a lot of writing.  Because I’ve had to have some legal background, at least I know where to look on certain things.”

[Read more →]

Tags: Excellent Article, eligibility by David-Crockett
2 Comments »

ObamaRelease YourRecords

New Ad - Obama’s Lack of Eligibility - The Three Enablers of the Cone of Silence in Washington DC - 24 May 2010 issue Washington Times National Weekly - Page 5 - [ New Ad Embedded Below ]

This “The 3 Enablers of the Cone of Silence in Washington DC” ad shows us who are the three enablers in our American system of government who are permitting Obama’s usurpation of the Office of the Presidency in violation of Article II, Section 1, Clause 5 of the U.S. Constitution. Obama was born a British Subject under British Nationality Laws since his father was a British Subject in 1961 and was only visiting the USA.

Obama’s father was never a U.S. Citizen, nor even an immigrant to the USA. Just like McCain is a U.S. Citizen because when he was born in Panama his father was a U.S. Citizen, Obama was a British Subject when born since his father was a British Subject. How can a person who is born a British Subject ever be considered a “natural born Citizen” of the USA?

[Read more →]

Tags: Natural Born Citizenship, eligibility, general, natural born citizen by David Crockett
2 Comments »

The first comment below is from a “conservative commenter” at one of my ORYR Facebook groups.  The comment is typical misinformation of what you see posted by the paid Obots across the web.  The second comment is a rebuttal courtesy of Attorney Mario Apuzzo.

The misinformation that is being spread needs to be flushed out with facts.  The Obots, and the misinformed, never leave any links to back their claims up.  When you respond with facts they just attack and run.

[Read more →]

Tags: Eligibility Crisis, Mario Apuzzo, eligibility, general by David-Crockett
2 Comments »

Also read DC Knows that Obama is Ineligible for Office

DEMOCRAT SENATOR PATRICK LEAHY AND OTHERS “RESOLVED” THAT IT TOOK TWO CITIZEN PARENTS TO BE A “NATURAL BORN CITIZEN”
by Tim DeJong

(May 17, 2010) —  The simple truth in evidence is Obama’s own declaration that he was born of a British father and is therefore not a “natural born Citizen.”

The Constitution is a modest document. Much of its meaning is in what is usually called common law. Some assume common law refers to Blackstone or English Common Law. The framers and many justices, Joseph Story among them, have referred to Vattel as our common law. Given that the first school of law established at a college in the Congress United (between the Revolution and the ratification) was that created at William and Mary by Thomas Jefferson, when James Madison was its president, and among its first students was John Marshall, and the stated structure of the curriculum was Law of Nations based upon Vattel and Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations. Can there be any doubt about the intent of the framers when justices including subsequent Chief Justice John Marshall cited Vattel when quoting “born on the soil of parents who are its citizens?” When the principal author of the 14th amendment, John Bingham, cites Vattel “about which there has never been doubt,” the meaning of “natural born Citizen” is confirmed for at least the twentieth time.

[Read more →]

Tags: Constitutional Backgrounders, DC Knows Obama Doesn't Qualify, Eligibility Crisis, eligibility, general by David-Crockett
1 Comment »

- New Hawaii law shuns Obama birth document requests -

(AP)HONOLULU — It’s now law in Hawaii that the state government can ignore repetitive requests for President Barack Obama’s birth certificate.

Republican Gov. Linda Lingle signed into law Wednesday a bill allowing state government agencies not to respond to follow-up requests for information if they determine that the subsequent request is duplicative or substantially similar to a previous request.

The law is aimed at so-called “birthers,” who claim Obama is ineligible to be president. They contend the Democratic president was born outside the United States, and therefore doesn’t meet a constitutional requirement for being president.

Lingle didn’t elaborate on her reasons for signing the bill, but state Health Director Dr. Chiyome Fukino previously issued statements saying that she’s seen vital records that prove Obama was born in Hawaii and is a natural-born American citizen.

[Read more →]

Tags: Dr. Chiyome Fukino, Hawaii investigation, eligibility, general by David-Crockett
3 Comments »